Last spring, Ted, experienced one of the worst hailstorms he could remember at his Grapevine home. Baseball-sized hail pummeled his roof, left dents in his metal siding, and shattered a few windows in a matter of minutes. After the storm cleared, Ted felt relieved knowing he had home insurance. He assumed it would fully cover the damages—after all, that’s what insurance is for, right?
When Ted went to file his hail damage claim, he was shocked at the insurance provider's response. His homeowners policy only reimbursed a fraction of the cost for his aging roof, and the hail deductible was far higher than he anticipated. He did not remember that he had a separate deductible for hail that had been raised when his policy last renewed.
To make matters worse, a neighbor mentioned that filing this claim for hail damage might affect his premiums in the future. Ted now wondered why even had a homeowners insurance policy. Frustrated and confused, Ted realized he didn’t truly understand how hail claims worked—and he’s not alone.
Hailstorms are a part of life in Texas, but misconceptions about how insurance covers hail damage can lead to unpleasant surprises. Let’s explore the three biggest myths about hail claims and what Texas homeowners like Ted need to know to protect their property.
Myth 1: Hail Damage Is Fully Covered, No Matter the Roof's Age
Ted had always assumed that his home insurance would cover the full cost to repair or replace his roof damage after a hail storm would blow through Grapevine. However, like many homeowners in Texas, he didn’t realize his policy included a roof payment schedule tied to the age of his roof. And his roof was 16 years old now.
The Reality
Many standard home insurance policies in Texas now calculate roof claim payouts based on actual cash value (ACV) rather than replacement cost. These roof payment schedules have a steep decline in how much the insurance claim will pay for roofs older than 10 years. Since actual cash value policies deduct for depreciation as the roof ages, the less money you receive towards the cost of repairs. For Ted, this meant a significant out-of-pocket expense to replace his 16-year-old roof.
How to Avoid Issues
- Review your homeowner policy to understand how your roof is covered.
- Consider upgrading to a policy with replacement cost coverage for your roof, which pays the full cost to replace it less the deductible, regardless of age.
- Work with a trusted roofer to inspect your roof and repair it when needed. This will prolong its lifespan and reduce the chance of making an unneeded hail damage insurance claim.
Myth 2: You Can File Multiple Hail Claims Without Consequences
Ted also believed his insurance was there for every hailstorm, big or small. After all, why pay premiums if you’re not going to use your coverage? Talking with other homeowners in his Grapevine neighborhood, there was confusion about how types of claims affect your homeowners insurance.
The stories about the homeowners insurance market from across the state have been plentiful. But after hearing his neighbors discuss rising premiums and non-renewals, Ted realized the insurance companies might not be operating as he had always perceived. The frequent claims might not be worth it.
The Reality
Homeowners insurance companies in Texas are cracking down on repeat claims. Filing multiple claims—especially for minor damage—can lead to higher premiums or even policy cancellation. To discourage small claims, many insurers have implemented higher wind and hail deductibles, meaning homeowners pay more out of pocket before insurance kicks in.
How to Avoid Issues
- Recognize that not all hail events in your general area require you start the insurance claims process.
- Perform regular inspections and pay for minor repairs out of pocket to avoid filing unnecessary claims, especially for cosmetic issues.
- Given how high homeowners insurance deductibles are in hail-prone areas, save for claims for significant damage.
Myth 3: The Insurance Company Automatically Pays for All Hail-Related Damage
Most Texans, whether they are in Grapevine or Midland, automatically see a hail damage claim as a driver to improve their home. This was largely the case for many years as Texas homeowners like Ted were able to easily get repairs made on a replacement cost policy while also upgrading since deductibles were not being paid by most. Those days have created a new reality.
When Ted received his payout for the storm damage, he was surprised to learn that some damage from hail isn't covered at all. Cosmetic dents to his metal siding were excluded through a cosmetic damage exclusion. To top this off, his roof had some pre-existing wear and tear and part of that damage was deemed ineligible by the insurance provider.
The Reality
While most standard policies cover structural damage caused by hail, many have exclusions or restrictions. For example:
- Cosmetic damage, like dents in metal roofs, may not be covered.
- Damage caused by pre-existing conditions or lack of maintenance can result in denied claims.
- Claims must be filed promptly, with thorough documentation, or risk being denied.
How to Avoid Issues
- Document the condition of your roof and property before a storm occurs. This will help you be able to show weather damage from the latest storm.
- File claims quickly and provide documentation of damage with photos or videos.
- Keep your roof and property in good repair to prevent disputes over claim eligibility and maximize a fair settlement.
Why These Myths Matter to Texas Homeowners
Misunderstanding how hail claims work can leave homeowners like Ted facing unexpected expenses. Rising premiums, stricter coverage terms, and broader exclusions are reshaping the market for Texas homeowners insurance policyholders. To avoid surprises, homeowners need to fully understand their standard home insurance policies and adapt to the new reality of what comprehensive coverage means today.
How True Texas Home Insurance Protects You
True Texas Home Insurance offers clarity and protection in the face of Texas’s challenging weather risks. With replacement cost coverage for roofs and help navigating the claims process, our goal is to tailor home insurance to the needs of Texans. Working with our local, independent insurance agents allow homeowners to find policies that fit their needs, ensuring they’re not left in the lurch after a storm.
Ted learned the hard way that believing myths about hail claims can lead to costly mistakes. By understanding the realities of hail damage coverage and choosing a comprehensive policy through our True Texas Home Insurance program, homeowners can avoid surprises and protect their biggest investment.
Click the Button Below to Get True Texas Home Insurance Today.