A small but vibrant church in Lubbock was grappling with a significant challenge. Tim, the elder in charge of finances, was determined to find a way to provide health insurance for their pastor and two dedicated staff members. The cost of medical expenses has skyrocketed to the point that they feel like the church has to do something to offset that potential catastrophe.
However, with a limited budget and numerous ministries to support, the high costs of a traditional group insurance policy seemed out of reach. Tim was at a crossroads. “Is there a way we can offer some kind of health coverage without breaking the bank?” he wondered, feeling the weight of his responsibility to care for those who served the church faithfully.
Tim’s story is not unique. Across Texas, the thousands of small churches face the same dilemma. They want to provide health benefits for their staff but are constrained by the high health care costs associated with comprehensive plans. For these churches, catastrophic health insurance might be the solution they’re looking for.
The Financial Reality of Health Insurance for Small Churches
Small churches like Tim’s often operate on tight budgets, with every dollar carefully allocated to support the church’s mission and community outreach. The thought of paying for a traditional group health insurance policy, with its high premiums and extensive medical coverage, can be daunting. For many, it simply isn’t feasible. This leaves churches in a difficult position, wanting to care for their employees but struggling to afford the means to do so.
Tim knew that opting out of health benefits wasn’t an option either. Not only would it leave the staff vulnerable to financial hardship in the event of a medical emergency, but it could also impact the church’s ability to retain and attract dedicated employees. He also knew that a stipend to help cover individual health care plans on the ACA Exchange left a lot to be desired as well. That’s why Tim began exploring more affordable options and discovered the potential of catastrophic health insurance.
What Is Catastrophic Health Insurance?
Catastrophic health insurance is designed to provide a safety net for major medical emergencies like cancer treatments, heart attacks, or major accidents. Unlike traditional health plans, which cover a broad range of services from primary care doctor visits to prescription drugs, catastrophic plans focus on protecting against the unexpected and expensive events—hospitalizations, surgeries, or serious illnesses.
For Tim’s church, this meant they could offer some level of financial protection for their staff without the high monthly premiums associated with comprehensive plans. With catastrophic health insurance, the church’s employees would be covered in case of a significant medical event, alleviating the fear of being overwhelmed by medical bills. This approach provided peace of mind, knowing that the church could offer some support, even if it couldn’t cover every health need.
Why Catastrophic Health Insurance Is a Viable Option for Small Churches
Catastrophic health insurance is a viable option for small churches like Tim’s because it strikes a balance between cost and coverage. These plans typically come with much lower monthly premiums compared to traditional health insurance. For churches with limited resources, this can mean the difference between offering some form of health coverage and offering none at all.
Tim realized that while catastrophic insurance wouldn’t cover regular doctor visits or minor illnesses, it would protect his staff from the financial devastation of a severe health event. By opting for a catastrophic plan, his church could fulfill its desire to support its active employees without compromising its financial stability. Offering this type of coverage also showed the staff that their well-being was valued, which can boost morale and loyalty even when resources are tight.
Comparing Catastrophic Plans vs. Traditional Health Insurance
To understand the value of catastrophic health insurance, Tim needed to compare it to traditional health plans. Traditional group health insurance policies offer extensive coverage but come with a hefty price tag. These fully insured plans can be challenging for small churches because of the rising health costs and limited control over premiums and benefits. These plans tend to cost so much more because of required essential coverage from the ACA legislation and the fact that one sick employee can blow up the claim expenses.
In contrast, catastrophic plans typically have significantly lower monthly costs because they only focus on significant medical events rather than routine care. This makes them an attractive option for small churches, where every dollar counts. Although many Texans think they come with high deductibles, that is not the truth. The deductibles can remain manageable AND the overall savings on monthly premiums make them a practical choice for churches that want to provide some protection without overextending their budget.
For some churches, self-funded traditional health insurance plans may also be an option, offering more transparency and control over medical costs. However, these plans may not be offered if your employee count dips too low. That means for most small congregations, a catastrophic plan can provide a straightforward, affordable way to ensure their staff has health insurance coverage when it matters most.
How Employee Participation Can Affect Health Plans
Another aspect Tim considered was how the employee participation level could affect the health plan’s effectiveness. Most insurance companies want a larger pool of people to spread the cost of health care around the entire group. As a result, higher participation rates can potentially lower costs and ensure that the staff was adequately covered. However, with only three employees, the impact of participation was limited, and each person’s needs would significantly influence the choice of plan.
Pre-existing conditions and the health status of employees also play a role in securing insurance options for small churches since they can require more medical services than a healthier population. Tim knew that if the staff understood the limitations and benefits of catastrophic insurance, they would be more likely to participate, sharing the financial responsibility and supporting each other in times of need.
Compliance with Affordable Care Act Regulations
One of Tim’s concerns was whether the church would be required to offer a health plan under the federal government's Affordable Care Act (ACA) provisions. Fortunately, small churches with fewer than 50 employees are not mandated to provide health insurance. However, this didn’t stop Tim from wanting to offer some support.
Health Reimbursement Accounts (HRAs) also provide an alternative solution to obtaining individual health coverage. With an HRA, the church could allocate funds to cover certain health care expenses, giving employees more flexibility. Another option was to increase the payroll slightly, allowing employees to use the additional income to purchase their own coverage, whether through an ACA exchange or a catastrophic policy.
Budget Considerations for the Church Between Catastrophic & Traditional Health Plans
As Tim delved deeper into the options available, he knew that the church’s budget would be the deciding factor. Traditional health plans, with their broad coverage and lower deductibles, might offer more benefits, but they were far beyond the church’s financial means. He also knew that using health sharing plans could be trouble since they are not actually insurance, even though they are usually cost effective for most people. On the other hand, catastrophic plans, with their high deductibles and limited coverage, were more affordable but required careful planning to manage out-of-pocket costs.
Tim weighed the potential financial risks against the peace of mind that even limited coverage could provide. He also considered the costs of premiums and coverage limits, knowing that in a catastrophic event, the plan would significantly reduce the church staff’s financial burden. In the end, the decision came down to providing some level of protection versus none at all—a choice that many small churches must make.
Working with Insurance For Texans to Get Catastrophic Health Insurance
After considering all options, Tim reached out to Insurance For Texans for guidance because of their True Texas Church Insurance program. Specializing in helping Texas churches like his, the team at Insurance For Texans understood the unique challenges small congregations face. They worked with Tim to explore customized catastrophic health insurance plans that matched the church’s budget and met the needs of their staff.
By partnering with True Texas Church Insurance, Tim’s church could look across the marketplace and find the right coverage for their unique situation. Whether through a catastrophic plan or another creative solution, the team at Insurance For Texans was committed to ensuring that every church could protect its staff without compromising its mission.
Click The Button Below To Learn About Affordable Catastrophic Health Plans for Your Church Staff.